Formal Employment Is No Guarantee: What Teenagers’ First Work Experiences Can Look Like
On October 2, at the “Anxious Society” conference, Polina Artemovna Shishkina, an employee of Marketing Agency ES LLC, presented her paper, “Barriers to and Prospects for Employment Among Russian Teenagers.”
The paper presented findings from a qualitative sociological study exploring how minors enter the world of work, what opportunities and risks they associate with it, and what makes a first job a positive or unsafe experience.
What did the findings reveal?
The study identified four types of teenage employment, ranging from negatively deinstitutionalized employment, in which work takes the form of alienated labor, to the most socially acceptable type: positively institutionalized employment.
Early employment can be an important stage in a teenager’s development and socialization. However, its benefits depend not so much on whether a teenager has a job, but on the conditions under which they work.
The study highlighted that employment can be a valuable resource only when work is organized safely and voluntarily, without undermining the teenager’s main educational pathway.
However, in the absence of legal protection, respectful treatment by management, clear rules, and support from family members or mentors, early employment can become a space for exploitation and alienated labor, ultimately diminishing the perceived value of education.
---
About the author
Polina Shishkina is an employee of Marketing Agency ES LLC and a graduate of Saint Petersburg State University. She is the author of the study “Barriers to and Prospects for Employment Among Russian Teenagers,” presented at the “Anxious Society” conference on October 2.
More information about the session “Childhood in a Turbulent World: Risks and Resources for Overcoming Challenges,” held as part of the conference “Anxious Society 5: The World in an Era of Polycrisis — Inequalities, Uncertainty, and Hope”: